Legislative Bulletin

APRIL 6, 2001


Landmark clean-air legislation emerges in the legislature
 
Far-reaching legislation introduced in the state House and Senate this week would require the state's two largest electric utilities, CP&L and Duke Power, to dramatically lower emissions of nitrogen oxide (NOx) and sulfur dioxide from their 14 coal-fired power plants. The reductions would sharply lower atmospheric ozone and go a long way toward eliminating the haze often seen in the air in the western part of the state. The utilities would have to invest hundreds of millions of dollars in pollution-control equipment at the plants, with the costs passed along to consumers.

Left: CP&L's Roxboro plant is one of the 14 coal-fired plants in the state.

The legislation, sponsored in the House by Rep. Martin Nesbitt (D-Buncombe) and in the Senate by Sen. Steve Metcalf (D-Buncombe), would require the utilities to slash sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxide emissions by roughly 70 percent over the next 12 years. Officials at CP&L and Duke Power say they can support the legislation, which would make North Carolina a national leader in cleaning up the air.

The air-quality improvements at the 14 coal-fired power plants mandated by the legislation are on top of reductions CP&L and Duke Power agreed to make last October during proceedings by the state Environmental Management Commission. The federal EPA had required the state to submit a plan for sharply reducing the amount of ozone-causing emissions coming from North Carolina and blowing into Northeastern states.

"CP&L is committed to cleaning up North Carolina's air, and we're demonstrating that commitment through our efforts to reduce NOx emissions -- 40 percent in the last six years," the utility said in a press statement. "If North Carolina wants to adopt these new clean air standards and aggressive timetable that far exceed both federal regulations and what other states have done, this legislative package is a way to accomplish that goal without jeopardizing the reliability and affordability of electricity," the statement continues.

Duke Power spokesman Joe Maher said the legislation "has goals that are aggressive but achievable."

Reducing emissions from the 14 coal-fired power plants is half of the state's two-pronged strategy toward cleaner air. The state also is working to reduce emissions from cars and trucks. Legislation passed two years ago stipulates that, beginning in 2004, only low-sulfur gasoline can be sold in the state. That law also tightens up on vehicle inspections and extends the vehicle emissions testing law, which now is in effect in the state's nine most urban counties, to 48 counties over the next could of years. Legislation was introduced this week that implements that two-year-old law, including raising the fee for a vehicle emissions test from $19.40 to $33.50.

Retrofitting the coal-fired power plants -- most of which are 30 years old or older -- will be expensive. "
We estimate it will cost our company $700 million above what we have already committed to do (in the EMC proceeding last fall), which is about $500 million," said CP&L spokesman Keith Poston. 

Bill Ross (left), secretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources, applauded the legislation. "An air quality plan that produces significant reductions in nitrogen oxide and sulfur dioxide emissions from North Carolina's coal-fired power plants will help our environment, benefit public health and improve our quality of life."

"We applaud the effort of the involved parties -- legislators, energy companies and environmental groups, to come up with a reasonable plan that accomplishes those goals," Ross added. "Significant nitrogen oxide and sulfur dioxide reductions will also produce related benefits: increased visibility, reduced haze, decreased ozone levels, and reduced mercury and fine particulate emissions."

The legislation contains specific language directing the state Utilities Commission to allow the utilities to recover from their customers the money they invest in clean-air equipment. "The commission shall allow each electric utility to recover all just, reasonable and prudently incurred environmental compliance expenditures through an environmental compliance expenditure recovery factor that is separate from the electric utility's rate base," the bill says.

"The commission shall set the environmental compliance expenditure recovery factor for each utility at least annually. The commission shall base the environmental compliance expenditure recovery factor on the electric utility's projections for its environmental compliance expenditures for the next calendar year. The commission shall incorporate into the environmental compliance expenditure recovery factor determination the experienced under-recovery or over-recovery of the electric utility's environmental compliance expenditures incurred during the previous calendar year," the bill further says.

Poston said CP&L estimates that recovering the investment the utility will be required to make will raise the average residential power bill by $5 a month. Commercial and industrial customers, which use substantially more electricity, would see much larger increases, he said. 
 
Return to Page One

 

Visit us at 225 Hillsborough Street, Suite 460, Raleigh, N.C.
Write to us at P.O. Box 2508, Raleigh, N.C. 27602
Call us at 919.836.1400 or fax us at 919.836.1425
e-mail:
info@nccbi.org

Co_pyright © 1998-2001, All Rights Reserved